![]()
| 1. Unknown HOARE, b. between 1871 and 1888 |
We can see from the 1841 census return that Edward Hoare was born in Merth
yr Tydfil in Glamorganshire, Wales where we can see him living with his pa
rents and siblings in 1841:
Edward Hoare 30 Gardener
Mary Hoare 30
William Hoare 15
Thomas Hoare 4
Edward Hoare 9 months
Rachel Rees 20 FS
__________
In 1851, Edward was still living with his parents at Pedwranfach, Merth
yr Tydfil, Glamorganshire, Wales:
Edward Hoare Head Mar 43 Gardener and Seedsman Glamorgan Merthyr Tydfil
Mary Hoare Wife 42 Glamorgan Merthyr Tydfil
Edward Hoare Son 10 Scholar Glamorgan Merthyr Tydfil
Maryann Hoare Daur 8 Scholar Glamorgan Merthyr Tydfil
John James Hoare Son 2 Glamorgan Merthyr Tydfil
William Hoare Son 6 months Glamorgan Merthyr Tydfil
Margaret Lewis Servant UnM 22 House Maid Cardigan Mount
Edward Sr. employed 3 men and 1 female.
__________
In 1861, the family was living at Junction(?) Hotel, Loch Y Wain, Llanwonn
o, Merthyr Tydfil, Glamorganshire:
Edward Hoare Head Mar 53 Inkeeper and Farmer 3.5 acres Glamorgan Merthyr
Mary Hoare Wife 52 Glamorgan Merthyr
Edward Hoare Son 20 Railway Clerk Glamorgan Merthyr
Mary Ann Hoare Daur 18 Scholar Glamorgan Merthyr
John J Hoare Son 12 Scholar Glamorgan Merthyr
Margaret Lewis Serv UnM 33 House Servant Candiganshire
__________
In 1871, he was lodging at 24 Vincent Square on the corner of Alfred Stree
t, Westminster, London, having recently married Elizabeth:
Job Toop Head M 50 Cabproprietor Dorset
Mary Ann Toop Wife M 46 Somerset Bridgewater
Mary Ann Toop Daur 12 Middlesex Knightsbridge
John Doyleaf Lodger M 50 Carpenter Middlesex London
Emma Doyleaf Wife M 46 Middlesex London
George Doyleaf Son 12 Middlesex Westminster
Edward Hoare Lodger M 32 Corporal Royal Engineers Wales Merthyr Tydfil
Elizabeth Hoare Wife M 36 Surrey Egham
__________
Edward married Elizabeth Knibbs (aka opera singer Lizzie Lemure) in 1871 a
nd they went off together to live in Chicago, Illinois, USA. They separat
ed after about 10 years and eventually divorced in 1888 due to Edward's in
fidelity with Emily Knibbs, identified in the divorce as his neice.
__________
We can see them in 1880, living at Jefferson, Cook, Illinois,:
Edward Hoar Head Mar 40 Wales
Elizabeth Hoar Wife Mar 47 England
Emily Clark Niece 17 England
Carrie Seymore Adopted Daughter 25 Canada
The original census return shows Carrie Seymore as an adopted daughter w
ho was either widowed or divorced.
I suspect that the girl named as Emily Clark was quite probably Elizabeth
's niece, Emily Knibbs, who later went on to have an affair with and th
en marry Edward Hoare.
__________
Edward divorced Elizabeth and married her niece Emily Knibbs in 1888.
__________
In 1895, Edward and family were living at Elizabeth, Union County, New Jer
sey:
Edward Hoare
Emily Hoare
Edna Hoare
Doret Hoare
Lillian Hoare
__________
We can see Edward and Emily in 1900 with three children Edna, Darrette a
nd Lilian, living at Bayonne City, New Jersey, USA. The census states th
at they'd been married for 20 years.
Edward Hoare Head born Sep 1840 59 Mar (20 years) Civil Engineer Wales
Emily Hoare Wife born Apr 1863 37 Mar (20 years) England
Edna Hoare Daughter born Aug 18 1881 Illinois
Darrette Hoare Daughter born Jun 1890 9 New Jersey at School
Lillian Hoare Daughter born Feb 1893 7 England at School
Edward stated that he had been in the United States since 1870, and that E
mily had been there since 1879.
__________
Edward and the children were living at Nest End, Elizabeth Ward 10, Unio
n, New Jersey in 1910:
Edward Hoare Head Wid 69 Civil Engineer Wales
Edna Hoare Daur 28 Private Family Nurse Illinois
Dorette Hoare 19 New Jersey
Lillian Hoare Daur 17 New Jersey
__________
From the New York Times, September 4, 1913:
Major Edward Le M. Hoare.
Major Edward Le Mesurier Hoare, a consulting engineer, with offic
es at 30 Church Street, died on Monday at his home, 419 West 115th Stree
t, of heart disease, in his seventy-third year. For many years he was cons
ulting engineer of the Chicago and Northwestern Railroad and had a wide re
putation as a railroad engineer. Major Hoare was born in London and ca
me to America as a young man. Three daughters survive him.
__________
Edward was a Private in the British Army when his first wife, Elizabeth Kn
ibbs purchased his release but we see from his obituary in the New York Ti
mes, he assumed the rank of Major and the surname of Le Mesurier Hoare.
Also, in his daughter Dorette's wedding announcement in the New York Heral
d, Edward's name was given as Major Edward Le M. Hoare.
The record at Riverside Cemetery, Woodstock, Windsor County, Vermont sho
ws him as Edward Le M. Witten Hoare, so an even more intriguing twist to h
is name.
His daughter Edna is also buried at Riverside Cemetery.
__________
Edward was also involved in the Vermont Gold Rush in the early 1900's wh
en he established the Sunny Crest Mining Company.
__________
Our gratitude goes to the members and volunteers at Find A Grave web site for recording the details, f="http://findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi?page=gr&GRid=96635863">in memo
ry of Edward.
Elizabeth's father died in 1849 and we can see that in 1851, all of her si
blings were living at the Windsor Union Workhouse. Elizabeth was that litt
le bit older so I presume that at 15 or 16 years of age, she was deem
ed to be old enough to make her own way in the world. Unfortunately, I c
an see no sign of her in 1851.
Elizabeth had a daughter named Elizabeth Paley Knibbs, b.1853 at St Geor
ge in the East, Stepney, London. The father was William Paley. They didn
't marry.
The birth register states that Elizabeth was living at the Workhouse at t
he time of the birth.
__________
On 2 Feb 1853, Elizabeth was admitted to the Raine Street Workhouse, St Ge
orge in the East, Wapping, London. She was admitted on the order of her Ma
ster because she was pregnant. The records are a little confusing becau
se the Workhouse records indicate that Elizabeth and her daughter (also El
izabeth) were admitted on 2 Feb 1853, yet the baptism record for the daugh
ter says she was born on 2 July 1853.
The workhouse record also indicates that Elizabeth was married on 9 Sep 18
52, so was in fact married when she was admitted. There seems to be no rec
ord of a marriage in 1852.
I suspect that the daughter Elizbeth died at just a few weeks of age.
__________
We can see Elizabeth in 1861 living at 119 Bedford Street, Mile End Old To
wn, Tower Hamlets, Middlesex with her mother and brother Richard:
Mary Ann Knibbs Widow 45 Laundress Bow Devonshire
Elizabeth Knibbs Daughter Unmarried 25 Egham Surrey
Richard Knibbs Son Scholar 14 London Middlesex
Sarah Foster Lodger 25 Needlewoman Hertford
__________
Newspaper articles show that Elizabeth performed as Lizzie Lemure at the f
ollowing places during her career as a Serio-Comic:
Alexandra Hall, Peter Street, Manchester, England - August-November, 1870
Winchester Music Hall, Southwark Bridge Road, London, England - December 1
869-June 1874
The Area Almanack and Annual from 1874, lists Lizzie as a Serio-Comic Sing
er.
__________
From The Era - Sunday 10 July 1870:
__________
From The Era - 17 July 1870:
BELFAST
SHAKESPEARE HOTEL. - (Proprietress, E. Grey.) - The attraction of two bal
lets a night, executed by the Sisters Howard and the "Can-Can" Troupe, pro
ve sufficient to draw crowded houses. Mies Jenny Blanche (serio-comic) ma
de her first appearance on Monday. Miss Lemure sings her rattling serio-co
mic effusions In taking style, and receives much applause. Mr M. P. Fost
er is a satisfactory performer, and is appreciated.
__________
Lizzie's name regularly appeared in "The Era Almanac" between 1868 and 18
77 as a Serio-Comic or Serio-Comic Singer.
__________
From the Liverpool Journal of Commerce - 17 October 1870:
The New Star Music-Hall
The program of this evening's performances at this popular place of reso
rt was of its usual pleasing character. Between the highly artistic beauti
es of the operatic selection and the vulgar eccentricities of the "Americ
an Entertainment," a well-varied series of attractions presented somethi
ng suitable to every one's taste. A crowded hall and an enthusiastic audie
nce testified to a hearty appreciation of this sample of managerial skill.
............................. Miss Madeline Roe, a pleasing vocalist, a
nd a pretty blonde to boot, and Mr. Archibald Mann, an old favourite, bo
th ballad singers, and Miss Lizzie Lemure, a piquant seriocomic brunett
e, received very deserved applause...........
__________
Copies of newspaper cuttings have revealed that Elizabeth married Edward H
oare in 1871 at Scarborough, Yorkshire England. He was a Private in the B
ritish army, and she was an opera singer. They separated in 1880 after 9 y
ears and eventually divorced in 1888. Elizabeth divorced Edward on the gro
unds of his adultery with her niece, Emily Knibbs.
Elizabeth and Edward Hoare went to live in Chicago, Illinois, USA, a
nd in 1880, an Emily Knibbs (said to be her niece from England) went to li
ve with them. We can see from newspaper cuttings related to Elizabeth's di
vorce from Edward, that she was a fairly wealthy woman.
__________
A playbill from 1867, featuring "Miss Lemure" at the McDonald's Music Hal
l, High Street, Hoxton, London
__________
It's very much a long shot because of the age difference, but I do wond
er if it was Elizabeth, living at Little Grant, Grant County, Wisconsi
n, at the time of the 1880 census:
Benjamin Garthwait Head Mar 68 Farmer England
Issabell Garthwait Wife 67 Keeping House England
Lizzie Hore 37 Wid Mother England
Libbie Hore 5 Daur Wisconsin
Elizabeth seemed to disappear after she separated from Edward, and we kn
ow from later divorce records that they had a child, somewhen after 187
__________
An extract from the Rocky Mountain News (Denver Co.) 27 July, 1888:
HER FAITHLESS HUSBAND
CHICAGO, July 26. - Lizzie Lemure's life romance was told in Judge Baker
's court to-day, and a sadder one is seldom recorded, even in divorce anna
ls. Lizzie Lemure was a famous London opera singer, a protege of Lord Geor
ge Paget, and as a friend and contemporary of Ada Isaacs Monken, the "Maze
ppa" of Astley's theatre, she frequently met the Prince of Wales, and h
er mezzo-soprano voice was well-known to London opera goers. An artist's a
ffections are proverbially erratic. Lizzie Lemure's were entrapped by t
he Adonis-like person of a private in the British army. There was nothi
ng of Edward Hoare but his magnificent physical beauty and manly strengt
h. In his red coat and "shako" me might have entrapped the heart of a bett
er dowered bride than Lizzie Lemure. A private soldier's pay, however, mak
es him susceptible to any woman of means, and Lizzie Lemure had �8,00
0, so in 1870 Lizzie Lemure and Edward Hoare were married. The opera sing
er gave the soldier $130 to buy his discharge in the army, but she affir
ms that he did not spend it for that purpose. According to her statemen
t, he deserted from the ranks and came to Chicago. She followed him in s
ix months. With her money a house was purchased at Park Ridge and Mrs. Hoa
re's activity and energy procured for her husband the position of civil en
gineer on the Northwestern railroad, which position he has held for fourte
en years. The couple's life was commonplace but happy in Park Ridge unt
il eight years ago. In 1880, not having been blessed with children, Mrs. H
oare brought over from England her sixteen-year-old niece, Emily Knibbs. E
mily was not pretty, but she was young and vivacious. "She lived with M
r. Hoare and myself as one of the family" said Mrs. Hoare, "and for a lo
ng time I was far from accepting that my husband could be so base as to be
tray her. It came like a peal of thunder out of a clear sky when Emily bec
ame the mother of a child. She tearfully told me who was the father. It w
as Mr. Hoare. I taxed him and he confessed. I was so overcome that I beca
me ill, and when I could do so I took a trip to California. On my retu
rn I found that Mr. Hoare and my niece were living together at my house
.. I ordered her out and in a week Mr. Hoare left also. He told me he d
id not love me any more. He said he was bound to provide for and protect E
mily and her child. The brazen girl was ungrateful for all I had done f
or her. She took all my bric-a-brac and the hundred little articles I h
ad collected in twenty years, but I never chided my husband for his infam
y; I loved him very deeply." Mrs. Hoare buried her face in her hands and s
eemed to be going back in memory to the days of Lizzie Lemure and Ada Isaa
cs Monken and the Adonis soldier who captured the citadel of her heart.
"Did you give your husband any provocation for this treachery" enquir
ed Mrs. Hoare's lawyer.
Mrs. Hoare arose from her seat with flashing eye and swelling breast. T
he question dried her eyes. She seemed to be on the tragic boards aga
in as she said, with an intentionally and dramatic gesture that caused Jud
ge Baker to look up in astonishment. "Provocation! Well, yes. If you ca
ll taking him to Paris and spending �500 on him in a single month; if y
ou call giving him all of my �2,000 which I made on the stage and �550 le
ft to me by my mother in England; if you call that provocation, why, the
n, I suppose I gave him provocation. I loved him passionately. I was as tr
ue to him as any woman ever was to any man. Everything I had he got. He h
as absorbed it all, and to-day in the meridian of life I find myself heart
broken and penniless, with nothing but what kind friends give me in charit
y, while he lives in a hotel at Park Ridge, within a stone's throw of Emi
ly Knibbs, with whom he spends his time and on whom he lavishes his sala
ry as civil engineer. I have often rued the day when his fine form and sha
llow head lured me to this."
Miss Annie Shurfee said that Mrs. Hoare had only her house at Park Rid
ge and derived other necessaries for her maintenance from the lady neighbo
rs. Mr. Bonomy, a resident of Park Ridge, said that Hoare admitted to h
im that he was the father of Emily Knibbs' child, and told him th
at he no longer cared for his wife.
Judge Baker heaved a deep sigh as he told the lawyer that Lizzie Lemure
's was a sad story, and she might have a divorce.
__________
An extract from The Daily Interocean Newspaper, Chicago Il, 27 July 188
8:
AN OPERA SINGER'S DIVORCE.
Mrs. Elizabeth Hoare, of Park Ridge, secured a decree of divorce yester
day, before
Judge Baker from her husband, Edward Hoare, civil engineer for the Chica
go and Northwestern Railroad Company at a salary of $125 a month. Mrs. Hoa
re said she was married to defendant Feb. 27, 1870, at Scarborough, Englan
d. About a year after the union they came to Chicago, and Mrs. Hoare obtai
ned her husbands present position. There was one child, born in Milwauke
e, which has since died. Mrs. Hoare testified that her husband was guil
ty of intimacy with Emily Knibbs, his 16-year-old niece, and that he h
ad a child by her. On May 6th last he left his wife and went living with M
iss Knibbs, and has since been contributing $40 a month toward the suppo
rt of his niece and her child. All this time Mrs. Hoare has been on the br
ink of starvation while Hoare boards in style at Park Ridge Hotel. Complai
nant said she has been kindly cared for lately by Mrs. W.P. Black, and Cap
tain Black appeared as attorney for Mrs. Hoare.
"I gave him no provocation for his conduct," said Mrs. Hoare. When I ma
rried him I had from $6,000 to $8,000. I took him to Paris with me. He w
as a soldier, and I gave him �31 to buy his discharge from the army. I ga
ve him money and valuables, and I brought several thousand dollars to th
is country with me and spent it with him. Even the little fortune th
at my mother left me he refused to account for. The gold watch that he h
as got in his pocket now I gave him. It cost me $200. It was my handsome g
old watch, and he exchanged it for another. When he left he took the furni
ture and all my little souvenirs that were made a present to me from so
me of the first artists in Europe. His niece is now staying with a frie
nd of his, a man that is working in the same office, and they are walki
ng and riding together, and I have never opened my lips from the time he l
eft until this moment"
The decree also provides for the payment of $30 a month alimony.
Mrs. Hoare's maiden name was Lizzie Lemure. She was a London opera sing
er some twenty years ago, and a protege of Lord George Paget. As a frie
nd of Ada Isaacs Menken, the Mazeppa of Astley's Theater, she frequently m
et the Prince or Wales. Hoare was a private of the British Army. t>
__________
The Sun (New York) reported the following on Friday. July 27, 1888:
HER FAITHLESS HUSBAND
He Transferred his Affections to his Wife's Niece.
CHICAGO, July 26, - Lizzie Lemure's life romance was told in Judge Baker
's court this morning. Twenty years ago Lizzie Lemure was a London opera s
inger and a prot�g� of Lord George Paget. She fell in love with a priva
te in the British army, Edward Hoare. A private soldier's pay made him sus
ceptible to any woman of means, and Lizzie Lemure had $80,000. So, in 187
0, Lizzie Lemure and Edward Hoare were married. The opera singer gave t
he soldier
$160 to buy his discharge from the army, but she affirms that he did not s
pend it for that purpose. He deserted from the ranks and came to Chicag
o. She followed him in six months. With her money a house was purchas
ed at Park Ridge, and Mrs. Hoare's activity and energy procured her husba
nd a position of civil engineer on the North Western Railroad, which posit
ion he has held for fourteen years. The couple's life was happy in Park Ri
dge until eight years ago.
In April, 1850, having no children, Mrs. Hoare brought over from England h
er 16-year-old niece, Emily Knibbs. Emily was not pretty, but she was you
ng and vivacious. "She lived with Mr. Hoare and myself as one of the famil
y." said Mrs. Hoare, "and for a long time I was far from suspecting th
at my husband could be so base as to betray her. It came like a peal of th
under out of a clear sky when Emily became the mother of a child. She tear
fully told me who was the father. It was Mr. Hoare. I taxed him, and he co
nfessed. I was so overcome that I became ill, and when I could do so I to
ok a trip to California. On my return I found that Mr. Hoare and my nie
ce were living together at my house. I ordered her out, and in a week M
r. Hoare left also. He told me that he did not love me any more. He sa
id he was bound to provide for and protect Emily and his child. The braz
en girl was ungrateful for all I had done for her. She took all my bric-a-
brac and the hundred little articles I had collected in twenty years., b
ut I never chided my husband for his infamy. I loved him very deeply."
"Did you give your husband any provocation for his treachery?" asked Mr. H
oare's lawyer.
"Provocation? Well, yes if you call taking him to Paris and spending �5
00 pounds on him in a month. If you call giving him all of my �2,000 whi
ch I made on the stage, and �650 left me by my mother in England two yea
rs ago - if you call that provocation, why, then I suppose I gave him prov
ocation. I loved him passionately: I was as true to him as any wom
an is to any man. Everything I had he got. He has absorbed it all, and to-
day, in the meridian of life, I find myself heartbroken, penniless, with n
othing but what kind friends give me in charity, while he lives in a hot
el at Park Ridge, within a stone's throw of Emily Knibbs, upon whom he lav
ishes his salary as a civil engineer. I have often rued the day when his f
ine form and shallow head lured me to this."
Judge Baker told the lady she might have the divorce she sought. >
__________
From the Baltimore Sun, July 27, 1888:
A Sad Romance.�Twenty years ago Lizzie Lemure was a L ondon opera singer a
nd a protege of Lord George Puget. A friend and contemporary of Ada Isaa
cs Monken, the famous Mazeppa of Ashley's Theatre, she frequently met t
he Prince of Wales. Lizzie married in 1870 a private of the British arm
y, Edward Hoare. She had $80,000 and he had nothing but bis pay. Hoare des
erted and went to Chicago. Mrs. Hoare�s energy procured for her husband t
he position of civil engineer on the North western Rail road, which positi
on he has held for fourteen years. The couple�s life was commonplace but h
appy in Park Ridge until eight years ago. In April, 1880, not having be
en blessed with children,. Mrs. Hoare brought over from England her sfxtee
n-year-old niece, Emily Knibbs. Emily was not pretty, but she was young a
nd vivacious. Yesterday in court, in divorce proceedings. Mrs.Hoare charg
ed her husband with betraying Emily and squandering his wife�s money. T
he divorce was granted.
__________
From the South Wales Echo, 13 August, 1888:
A LONDON ROMANCE
Twenty years ago Lizzie Lemure was an opera singer in London, the frie
nd of Lord George Paget and Ada Isaacs Menken. She fell in love with Edwa
rd Hoare, a private in the British Army�tall, handsome, and intelligent. S
he had a fortune of �16,000; bought Hoare's discharge�she says that he des
erted and stole the discharge money�and, in 1870, married him and emigrat
ed to Chicago. Ten years brought them no children, and, in 1880, Mrs Hoa
re imported her niece, Emily Knibbs, sixteen years old, to live with the
m. One day Emily had a baby, and confessed that Hoare was its father. M
rs Hoare left the house. On her return she found her husband and Emily liv
ing together as man and wife. Now she has sued for a divorce, which Jud
ge Baker, of Chicago, has granted. Mrs Hoare says :�" I am heartbroken, pe
nniless, and rue the day when that man's fine form and handsome head lur
ed me from my profession and my country."
__________
Sadly, I've been unable to identify what happened to Elizabeth after her d
ivorce from Edward.
One possibility is that she took on the surname of Lemure as a permanent r
ather than a stage name. The was an Elizabeth Lemure who was possibly marr
ied to a man named Cady Howe. In 1883, Elizabeth Lemure was named as the M
other of the Bride at the wedding of Cady's daughter, Josephine.
Cady Howe had been connected with Barnum's, Forpaugh and other circuses f
or 50 years, retiring in 1889.
This is pure speculation, but fits the timeline for Elizabeth's separati
on from her husband Edward Hoare and indeed, both Elizabeth and Cady we
re heavily involved in entertainment.
The only reference we have to this child is from the divorce proceedin
gs of Elizabeth and Edward where it is identified that they had a child, b
orn in Milwaukee, but it had since died.
The only possiblity I've ever found was a child named Libbie Hore who w
as living with her mother, Lizzie Hore in 1880 in Wisconsin. They were liv
ing in the househild of Benjamin Garthwait and his wife Issabell. The on
ly information is that Libby was born in Wisconsin and both her parents w
ere born in England.